Car insurance

Car insurance priced on your driving, not your patience

The national average driver spent $1,282 on auto insurance in the most recent NAIC data year, up 14% in twelve months. Here is what that looks like state by state, which limits are worth buying, and the shortest path to a lower renewal.

Standard and high-risk carriers SR-22 filings handled Same-day proof of insurance

undefined

undefined

undefined

undefined

undefined

undefined

Car insurance got expensive for reasons that have nothing to do with your driving. Repair costs, medical inflation and total-loss frequency all rose at once. The Insurance Information Institute, using NAIC data, puts the countrywide average expenditure at $1,282 in 2023, up 14.0% from $1,127 the year before. The average incurred loss per collision claim reached $7,191 in 2022, a 17.6% jump in one year. Your renewal reflects that math, not a personal judgment.

What you control is structure and shopping. Two drivers on the same street with the same record routinely pay 30% to 50% differently because carriers weight credit-based insurance scores, mileage, vehicle repair cost and prior-carrier history differently. There is no single cheapest insurer; there is a cheapest insurer for your profile in your state, and it changes when your profile changes.

The other lever is limits. State minimums were written decades ago and have not kept pace with what a hospital charges. Texas, for example, requires 30/60/25 under the Texas Department of Insurance auto guide: $30,000 in bodily injury per person, $60,000 per accident and $25,000 in property damage. One serious injury or one late-model SUV blows through that, and the balance is yours personally. Raising liability limits to 100/300/100 usually costs far less per month than most people guess, because the frequency of large claims is low even though the severity is high.

Below: what coverage each part of the policy actually does, average premiums by state from NAIC, the rating factors carriers weight most, the limits we recommend and why, SR-22 mechanics if you need a filing, and the discounts that survive contact with reality. Rates, required coverages and filing rules vary by state, so verify specifics for where your car is garaged.

What it costs

Average annual car insurance premium by state

NAIC 2023 data, the most recent full-market figures available. Average expenditure is what drivers actually spent per insured vehicle; combined average premium is the filed premium across liability, collision and comprehensive.

StateAverage expenditureCombined average premium
Florida$1,864$1,994
New York$1,753$1,896
Georgia$1,555$1,746
Michigan$1,443$1,572
Texas$1,429$1,727
California$1,223$1,417
Pennsylvania$1,155$1,274
Ohio$947$1,038
Countrywide$1,282$1,438

Source: NAIC 2023 Auto Insurance Database, average premium and expenditure tables. NAIC assumes every insured vehicle carries liability but not necessarily collision or comprehensive, so expenditure runs below combined premium. Your own rate depends on your record, vehicle, credit-based insurance score where permitted, and coverage choices.

Rating factors

What actually moves your premium

Ranked roughly by how much weight carriers give them in most states.

  • Where the car is garaged. Rating is by ZIP code, not state. Florida averaged $1,864 per vehicle against $947 in Ohio in 2023, and urban ZIPs inside a state often price 25% above rural ones.
  • Your at-fault and violation history. A single at-fault accident typically raises premium 20% to 45% for three to five years. A DUI usually moves you to a nonstandard carrier and often triggers an SR-22 filing.
  • Credit-based insurance score. Permitted in most states and heavily weighted where allowed, though California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan restrict or ban its use in auto rating.
  • The vehicle itself. Repair cost, parts availability, ADAS sensor calibration and theft rate matter more than sticker price. Two cars with the same MSRP can differ 30% on collision premium.
  • Annual mileage and use. Commuting 25,000 miles a year prices well above 6,000. Telematics programs can discount 10% to 30% for consistent low-mileage, smooth driving, and can also increase rates in some programs.
  • Continuous coverage. A lapse of even a day usually loses your prior-insurance discount and can shift you to a nonstandard tier for six to twelve months.
  • Deductible and limits. Moving collision from $500 to $1,000 typically cuts 8% to 15% of the collision portion. Raising liability limits costs far less proportionally than most drivers expect.

The limits we recommend, and why minimums are not enough

Liability limits are written as three numbers, for example 100/300/100. That is $100,000 in bodily injury per person, $300,000 per accident, and $100,000 in property damage. When the damage exceeds your limits, the shortfall is a personal debt, collectible against wages and assets in most states.

CoverageWhat it paysWhat to carry
Bodily injury liabilityOther people’s medical bills, lost wages and pain and suffering when you are at fault.100/300 at minimum; 250/500 if you have meaningful assets or income
Property damage liabilityTheir vehicle and any property you damage.$100,000. Average new-vehicle prices make $25,000 minimums inadequate
Uninsured/underinsured motoristYour injuries when the at-fault driver has no coverage or too little.Match your bodily injury limits; carriers must offer it in most states
CollisionYour vehicle after a crash regardless of fault, minus your deductible.Keep while the car is worth more than roughly $4,000; $500 or $1,000 deductible
ComprehensiveTheft, hail, flood, fire, vandalism and animal strikes.Keep alongside collision; often only $10 to $20 a month
Medical payments or PIPYour own medical bills and, with PIP, sometimes lost wages, regardless of fault.Required in no-fault states; elsewhere $5,000 to $10,000 is cheap coverage

Two coverages people skip and regret. Uninsured motorist protection is the one that pays when someone with a minimum policy or no policy at all injures you, which is a meaningful share of drivers in many states. And gap or loan-lease payoff coverage matters any time you owe more than the car is worth, since collision pays actual cash value, not your loan balance.

An umbrella policy is usually the cheapest liability you can buy. Once your auto limits reach 250/500, $1 million of personal umbrella coverage commonly runs $200 to $400 a year and extends over both your auto and home policies. See umbrella insurance for the qualifying limits carriers require underneath.

For a walk-through of how to size limits against your own assets, read how much car insurance do I need.

Nine ways to cut the bill that actually work

Discount lists are long and mostly small. These are the ones with real dollars behind them:

  • Shop at every renewal, not every five years. Carriers re-tier existing customers slowly and price new business aggressively. The same profile can differ 30% or more between two admitted carriers in the same state.
  • Bundle home or renters with auto. Multi-policy discounts commonly run 10% to 25% on the auto side, and renters insurance often costs less than the discount it unlocks.
  • Raise your collision and comprehensive deductible. Going from $500 to $1,000 typically saves 8% to 15% of that portion. Only do it if you can absorb the deductible in cash.
  • Drop collision on an old car. When annual collision and comprehensive premium exceeds about 10% of the car’s actual cash value, the coverage stops making sense.
  • Try telematics for one term. Low-mileage, smooth drivers commonly earn 10% to 30%. Check whether the program can raise your rate before you enroll.
  • Fix the mileage on file. Remote work has cut commutes for millions of drivers and carriers do not update it for you.
  • Claim the student and defensive-driving discounts. Good-student discounts for teens are among the largest single credits on a policy, and many states mandate a discount for approved defensive-driving courses.
  • Pay in full and go paperless. Installment fees plus a paid-in-full credit are frequently worth 5% to 10% combined.
  • Never let coverage lapse. A lapse costs more in lost discounts and tier placement than the month of premium you skipped.

What does not work: chasing an advertised rate that turns out to carry state minimum limits, or buying from a carrier with a poor claims reputation to save $8 a month. Our guide to lowering your car insurance premium covers the negotiation sequence in detail, including how to request a re-rate after a violation ages off your record.

SR-22s, lapses and getting back to standard rates

An SR-22 is a certificate of financial responsibility, not a type of insurance. Your carrier files it with the state to confirm you are carrying at least the required liability limits, and it notifies the state automatically if your policy cancels or lapses.

Rules are state-specific. In Texas, the Department of Public Safety requires an SR-22 after a suspension from a crash, a second or subsequent conviction for driving without liability insurance, or a civil judgment, and the filing must be maintained for two years from the conviction or judgment date, with a $100 reinstatement fee before a license is reissued. Other states commonly require three years. A non-owner SR-22 policy is available if you do not own a vehicle but still need to satisfy the requirement.

The filing itself is cheap, usually $15 to $25. The expensive part is the underlying rate, because the event that triggered the filing also moves you to a nonstandard tier. Three things shorten that period:

  1. Keep the policy continuously in force. A single cancellation restarts the clock and can re-suspend your license.
  2. Ask for a re-quote at each renewal and again at the three-year and five-year marks, when most violations stop surcharging.
  3. Take an approved defensive-driving course if your state allows a point reduction, then have your carrier re-rate the policy.

Our SR-22 guide covers filing timelines, non-owner policies and what happens if a payment is missed. We place these filings routinely, including for drivers who were nonrenewed by their previous insurer.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

What is the average cost of car insurance?

The countrywide average expenditure was $1,282 per insured vehicle in 2023, the most recent NAIC data year, up 14.0% from $1,127 in 2022. State averages ranged from about $947 in Ohio to $1,864 in Florida. Your own rate depends on ZIP code, record, vehicle and coverage choices far more than on the national figure.

Is full coverage worth it on an older car?

Compare annual collision and comprehensive premium against the car’s actual cash value. When that premium passes roughly 10% of the value, or the payout after your deductible would not meaningfully help, dropping to liability-only is defensible. Keep full coverage while you owe money, since lenders require it.

How much do liability limits cost to raise?

Less than most drivers expect. Moving from state minimums to 100/300/100 often costs $15 to $40 more a month, because severe claims are infrequent even though they are expensive. Given that a single hospital stay can exceed $100,000, this is usually the best value on the policy.

Will one accident raise my rate?

An at-fault accident typically raises premium 20% to 45% and surcharges for three to five years, depending on the carrier and state. Accident forgiveness riders can waive the first one if you bought the endorsement beforehand. Shopping after a surcharge often helps, since carriers weight the same event differently.

How long do I need an SR-22?

It varies by state. Texas requires two years from the date of the conviction or judgment, while many states require three. The filing must stay continuously in force, because your insurer notifies the state if the policy cancels, which can re-suspend your license and registration.

Does my credit affect my car insurance rate?

In most states, yes. Carriers use a credit-based insurance score that is related to but different from a lending score, and it carries significant weight. California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan restrict or prohibit its use in auto rating, so the same profile can be priced very differently across state lines.

Stop overpaying for the same coverage

One short form, then a licensed advisor runs your profile through standard and nonstandard carriers, including SR-22 filings, and shows you the limits worth buying.